|Lucy from Faces of People who may or may not be victims or perpetrators of|
Gabrielle Goliath makes a forthright stab in this direction in her new exhibition Faces of War, which appears on every level to be engineered to express “silence”.
Her visual and aural (in the Personal Accounts series) mode of presentation is shaped by this objective; in other words, all her artistic products are the result of a series of devices aimed at “silencing” the subjects.
In the photographic series Faces of People who may or may not be Victims or Perpetrators of Domestic Violence, she achieves this by adopting a uniform visual aesthetic that is defined by stripping back the details or visual indexes of identity that might shed light on them.
Paradoxically, she does this under the guise of offering up their faces for close inspection; you are confronted with cropped close-ups that allow you to detect almost every hair, blemish or wrinkle. In this way she encourages us to scrutinise these subjects closely, creating the illusion that if we sustain our gaze we will somehow learn whether they are victims or perpetrators of domestic violence.
Naturally, there is nothing about their appearance that provides evidence of either; there are no bruises, and what does a perpetrator look like? Is he white, black, and can a perpetrator be female? In leaving it up to the viewer to decide, Goliath forces us to confront our inbuilt prejudices around victims and perpetrators, setting up this macabre game where we get to decide their status. She gives us control in a context where we have none but in doing so she makes us complicit.
Of course, statistics and news reports tell us that most perpetrators of this kind of crime are men, so perhaps the guessing game in that regard is narrowed down by the gender profile of her random subjects who are strangers or people peripheral to her. The artist has no definitive knowledge about the status of her subjects.
They may be unaware of their own status; so often perpetrators of domestic violence aren’t able to acknowledge culpability and victims too may be in denial. It is also possible that none of these subjects may be victims or perpetrators, though our vexed history somehow demands and has shaped a dichotomised view of our society where you must be one or the other.
|Marc from Faces of People who may or may not be victims or perpetrators of|
Perhaps even the insidious impact of domestic violence on our society as a whole has rendered us all victims or perpetrators in the sense that we don’t act when it is clear someone is in trouble or is causing it. It is likely even that the phenomenon is a by product of our history and patriarchal culture.
The only feature these subjects have in common is that their faces are symmetrical, the result of digital manipulation. Presumably, this ensures that they appear one-dimensional and ideal, although this is also what makes them slightly abnormal. The portrait of Marc looks slightly freakish because of this device.
The two bodies of work on this show are united by a contradiction; by not showing us abuse or even victims or perpetrators of it, Goliath aims to direct our attention to it.
Does this work? Is Goliath not simply avoiding the topic and conspiring to maintain the silence around this crime? This is troubling because it embodies the stance of the perpetrator whose abuse includes securing the victim’s silence. She may successfully prove that domestic abuse can happen to anyone or be committed by anyone, that appearances are not reliable but, by reproducing the public face of domestic violence – silence – she fails to disrupt it.